In the world of comic books, unresolved mysteries often leave fans speculating for years, if not decades. Such is the case with Batman’s affiliation with the Justice League post-Crisis on Infinite Earths, a storyline that has puzzled readers for ages. The enigma revolves around Batman’s sudden decision to rejoin the Justice League after a significant period of detachment, where he formed and led another group known as the Outsiders. Despite the return being a substantial narrative development, the reasons behind it were never clarified, leaving a gap in Batman’s storied chronology.
The backdrop to this mystery starts when Batman, dissatisfied with the Justice League’s stance and seeking more autonomy in handling situations, decides to quit and form his own team, the Outsiders. This group was Batman’s brainchild, allowing him to operate without the constraints he felt were imposed upon him by the League. He led the Outsiders through various adventures, his leadership unmistakable yet often called into question by the very members he sought to guide without contention. This dissension within the ranks led to Batman disbanding the Outsiders, a move that was as decisive as his initial effort to form the team.
Subsequent to these events and somewhat unexpectedly, Batman found himself aligning once again with the Justice League. This rejoining was particularly curious because it happened during a tumultuous period in the DC Universe, post the reality-altering events of Crisis on Infinite Earths. The Justice League was undergoing its own transformations, with new members joining under Aquaman’s leadership in what was referred to as the Justice League Detroit era.
Batman’s return to the League was marked by his intention to train the new roster of heroes, a noble endeavor that nonetheless left readers wondering about the deeper motivations behind his decision. What was it that compelled Batman to come back to an organization he had previously deemed restrictive? And why, after taking such definitive steps to carve out his own path with the Outsiders, did he choose to return?
When approached about this lingering narrative thread, Gerry Conway, a prolific writer for the Justice League stories during that era, admitted that while he often seeded future plotlines in his storytelling, he left the series before providing an explanation for Batman’s return. This practice of planting story seeds with the intention to revisit them later is not uncommon in comics but has led to this particular unresolved issue regarding one of DC’s most iconic characters.
As the storyline progressed beyond Conway’s tenure, subsequent writers focused on developing new arcs without circling back to this dangling plot point. This left fans with ample room for speculation, and many have posited their own theories over the years. From a strategic standpoint, Batman rejoining could have been intended as a morale booster for the League, bringing back a seasoned and tactically minded hero into the fold. Alternatively, it could have stemmed from a desire for redemption or a newfound sense of duty towards a team he once saw as his family.
In a medium where continuity is as mutable as that of comic books, unresolved storylines are not unheard of. However, they often serve as fascinating glimpses into the creative process, illustrating how shifts in creative teams and editorial directions can lead to compelling narrative threads being left untied. For Batman’s mysterious return to the Justice League, it seems the curtain may never be fully drawn, leaving it as an intriguing footnote in the Batman mythology for fans and scholars to ponder.
Source